Outline and explain two ways in which the ownership of the media can affect the content of the news.
AQA
A Level
2024
👑Complete Model Essay
Free Essay Plan
Outline and Explain Two Ways in Which the Ownership of the Media Can Affect the Content of the News
This essay will explore two ways in which the ownership of the media can affect the content of the news. Firstly, it will discuss how media owners can act as agenda setters, influencing the prominence and framing of news stories. Secondly, it will examine how media concentration can lead to a narrower range of news sources and perspectives, limiting the diversity of information available to the public.
1. Agenda Setting
a) Definition and Explanation:
Agenda setting is the ability of the media to influence the salience of issues in the public consciousness. By deciding which stories to cover, how prominently to feature them, and how to frame them, media owners can shape public discourse and influence what people consider important.
b) Examples:
• Rupert Murdoch's News Corporation has been accused of using its media outlets to promote right-wing political agendas, often focusing on issues like immigration and social conservatism. • The BBC, a publicly funded broadcaster, is expected to maintain a neutral stance on political issues, but its editorial decisions can still reflect the values and priorities of its management.
c) Analysis:
The extent to which media owners can influence the agenda is dependent on the type of media they control. Newspapers, with their editorial freedom, tend to be more influential than television channels, which are subject to more regulation. Furthermore, the rise of online news and social media has diversified the media landscape, making it more difficult for any single owner to exert complete control over the agenda.
2. Media Concentration
a) Definition and Explanation:
Media concentration refers to the consolidation of ownership in the media industry, where a small number of companies control a large share of the market. This can lead to a narrowing of the range of news sources and perspectives available to the public.
b) Examples:
• In the UK, a few large media companies, such as News Corporation and the BBC, dominate the news market, leading to concerns about the limited range of voices and perspectives represented. • In the US, the rise of digital giants like Facebook and Google has created a new form of media concentration, with these companies controlling a substantial share of advertising revenue and user data.
c) Analysis:
Media concentration can lead to a homogenization of news content, with different outlets presenting similar stories from similar perspectives. This can limit the public’s ability to access a diverse range of information and form informed opinions on important issues. Furthermore, it can lead to a lack of accountability and scrutiny of powerful institutions, as less independent media outlets are willing to challenge the status quo.
Conclusion
In conclusion, this essay has outlined two ways in which the ownership of the media can affect the content of the news: agenda setting and media concentration. While media owners have a significant influence on what information reaches the public, the extent of their power is subject to various factors, including the type of media they control, the level of public scrutiny, and the emergence of alternative news sources. It is crucial to be aware of the potential impact of media ownership on news content and to critically evaluate information from diverse sources to form independent judgments.
How Ownership of the Media Can Affect the Content of the News
The ownership of media outlets plays a significant role in shaping the news we consume. Two key ways in which this manifests are through agenda-setting by owners and the narrowing of news sources due to concentrated ownership.
Agenda Setting and Content Control
Owners, particularly those with vested interests, can influence the content of news by acting as agenda-setters. They may directly influence editorial decisions, prioritizing certain stories over others or framing them in particular ways to align with their own perspectives and agendas. This can lead to the suppression of critical voices and the promotion of biased narratives. For example, a media mogul who also owns a major oil company may downplay coverage of climate change or present it in a way that protects their business interests.
Furthermore, owners can control content by appointing editors and journalists who share their views. This creates a culture where dissenting voices are marginalized, and the news output reflects the owner's political or economic stance. This form of control might be subtle, influencing the selection of interviewees, the tone of reporting, or the placement of stories within a news bulletin. While journalists are bound by ethical codes, the influence of ownership on the overall news agenda can be substantial.
Concentration of Ownership and Narrowing of Sources
The increasing concentration of media ownership in the hands of a few powerful corporations also raises concerns about the diversity of news sources and perspectives. When multiple media outlets are owned by the same entity, there is a risk of homogenization of content, where a narrow range of voices and viewpoints are represented. This limits the audience's exposure to different perspectives, potentially creating an echo chamber that reinforces existing biases.
Moreover, concentrated ownership can stifle investigative journalism and critical reporting. Smaller, independent outlets are often better positioned to challenge powerful interests, but they may struggle to compete in a market dominated by large conglomerates. This concentration of power can lead to a decline in journalistic independence and a reluctance to challenge the status quo, ultimately impacting the quality and diversity of news available to the public.
Conclusion
The ownership of the media has a profound impact on the content of the news. Agenda-setting by owners and the narrowing of sources due to concentrated ownership can shape public opinion, influence political discourse, and limit the diversity of voices and perspectives in the public sphere. Recognizing these influences is crucial for media literacy and critical engagement with the information we consume.
Free Mark Scheme Extracts
Answers in this band will show very good knowledge and understanding of two ways in which the ownership of the media can affect the content of the news.
There will be two applications of relevant material, eg owners may act as agenda setters and control content; concentration of ownership narrows the range of sources and of news.
There will be appropriate analysis, eg the extent to which effects may depend on type of media.