‘Economic problems were the main cause of Japanese expansionism in the 1930s.’ How far do you agree?
Level
AS Level
Year Examined
2023
Topic
The Industrial Revolution in Britain, 1750–1850
👑Complete Model Essay
‘Economic problems were the main cause of Japanese expansionism in the 1930s.’ How far do you agree?
Economic Problems and Japanese Expansionism in the 1930s
The assertion that economic problems were the main cause of Japanese expansionism in the 1930s holds significant weight, although it is crucial to acknowledge the intertwined role of militarism and long-held imperial ambitions. While economic hardships created a powerful impetus for expansion, they did not act in isolation.
Japan's rapid industrialization in the early 20th century created a dependence on imported raw materials and foreign markets. As the Great Depression ravaged the global economy, demand for Japanese exports plummeted, plunging the nation into economic crisis. By 1931, half of Japan's factories were shuttered, leaving millions unemployed and desperate. This dire situation fueled the desire for economic self-sufficiency through territorial expansion. Manchuria, for example, with its abundant resources, became an attractive target. The Japanese government argued that securing access to raw materials like coal and iron ore was essential for national survival.
The desire for economic security was further exemplified by Japan's establishment of plantations in its colonial holdings. Taiwan became a source of sugar, Manchuria supplied soybeans, and Korea provided rice. These commodities not only addressed domestic needs but also generated revenue through exports, primarily to the United States and Europe. This reliance on international trade, however, would later contribute to Japan's entry into World War II when the US threatened an oil embargo in 1941.
However, attributing Japanese expansionism solely to economic factors would be an oversimplification. As Louise Young argues in 'Japan's Total Empire,' the country's military elite held a long-standing belief in the necessity of territorial expansion for national security. Military leaders viewed control over areas like Korea as crucial for safeguarding Japan's strategic interests in East Asia. Furthermore, the military's prestige was deeply intertwined with battlefield victories, and imperial conquests provided opportunities for bolstering their standing.
The roots of Japanese imperialism can be traced back even further to the Meiji Restoration of 1868. This period marked a turning point as Japan embarked on a path of modernization and sought to establish itself as a major power on the world stage. Imperial expansion, with its promises of wealth, prestige, and influence, became intertwined with Japan's national identity.
The rise of militarism in the 1930s further propelled Japan towards expansion. The May 1932 incident, in which a group of army officers assassinated the Prime Minister and attacked government officials, highlighted the growing power of the military within Japanese society. As the country drifted closer to war, the military leadership, driven by a combination of nationalist ideology and opportunistic ambitions, seized control and steered Japan towards further conquests in Asia.
In conclusion, while economic problems undoubtedly played a significant role in driving Japanese expansionism in the 1930s, they cannot be viewed in isolation. Japan's actions were the result of a complex interplay of factors, including long-held imperial ambitions, a culture of militarism, and the perceived need for national security. Economic hardship provided a powerful catalyst, but it was ultimately the confluence of these factors that propelled Japan down a path of aggressive expansionism.
Note: History Study Pack Required
Score Big with Perfectly Structured History Essays!
Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...
History Study Pack.
✅ 1200+ Model Essays: Master your essay writing with expertly crafted answers to past paper questions.
✅ Exam Boards Covered: Tailored materials for AQA, Cambridge, and OCR exams.
🍃 Free Essay Plan
Introduction
Briefly introduce Japanese expansionism in the 1930s and state your overall argument in relation to the question. For example, to what extent do you agree that economic problems were the main cause?
Economic Problems as a Cause
Discuss the economic difficulties faced by Japan in the 1930s:
⭐Impact of the Great Depression on Japan's export-dependent economy
⭐Closure of factories, unemployment, and social unrest
⭐Japan's reliance on imported raw materials and food
Connect these economic problems to expansionist policies:
⭐Need to secure resources and markets in Manchuria, Korea, and Taiwan
⭐Establishment of plantations and exploitation of colonial resources
⭐Explain how this ties into the argument that economic woes drove expansion
The Role of Militarism
Analyze the influence of militarism on Japanese expansionism:
⭐Long-term strategic goals of the Japanese military elite (securing regional dominance)
⭐Desire for military prestige and expansion as a means to achieve it
⭐The Meiji Restoration as a turning point towards militarism and imperialism
⭐The May 1932 incident and the rise of military influence in government
Other Contributing Factors (Optional)
You may choose to briefly discuss other factors that played a role, such as:
⭐Nationalism and the idea of Japanese superiority
⭐Political instability and the weakness of civilian governments
⭐International context and the rise of other aggressive powers
Evaluation and Conclusion
Weigh the significance of economic problems against other factors:
⭐Acknowledge the interconnectedness of economic, military, and political factors
⭐State your final assessment of the relative importance of economic problems
⭐ Offer a nuanced conclusion that summarizes your argument
Extracts from Mark Schemes
Economic problems were the main cause of Japanese expansionism in the 1930s. How far do you agree?
Discussion of economic difficulties may consider how industrial Japan favoured the expansion of the country's empire because of the availability of raw materials. When the Great Depression hit the world this caused countries to no longer be able to import products from Japan, which is how Japan made up their economy from. These actions led Japan to fall into an economic crisis.
With the industrial expansion goal in mind, Japan established plantations in its colonial territories including those growing sugar in Taiwan, soybeans in Manchuria, and rice in Korea. These commodities helped develop the commercial side of Japan's economy through trading with the United States and Europe. Eventually, international trade would draw Japan into the Second World War when the United States threatened to cut off oil supplies in 1941. Japan was lacking in natural resources and building space, so their military invaded Manchuria in 1931. Japan then started gaining control in Korea and Taiwan. Japan took these actions because more than 40% of their food and raw materials were imported from these places.
As a result of the Great Depression, half of all of Japan's factories were closed by 1931 because no one was in a position to buy imported products from them. With half of the factories in Japan closing, it left many people without jobs and a way to get food for their family. In desperate moments, children were begging for food to passengers on passing trains and farmers had no choice but to eat tree bark to stay alive.
Discussion may also include the role of militarism.
Japan's imperial expansion in the 1930s was due to the long-term view taken by the country's military elite, argues Louise Young, author of 'Japan's Total Empire'. Japanese military leaders believed that seizing control of areas like Korea was vital to securing Japan's security in the East Asia region. In addition, the reputation of the military was largely based on battlefield successes, meaning imperial expansion boosted military prestige. The move towards imperialism began far earlier in 1868 with the Meiji restoration. The nation began a march towards imperialism and the inherent need for wealth, prestige and reputation that Japan equated with being an imperialistic military power.
Then in May 1932, a group of army officers murdered the current prime minister and attacked key government and banking officials. Japan's military and economic leaders decided to press for further conquests as they were close to going into the Second World War in search to consolidate political control and interests in rich resources that were in other parts of Asia. The military then started organising a Japanese military dictatorship which wasn't led by a specific leader. Japan became more like a dictatorship, but with a group of leaders and not a single person. Accept any other valid responses.