Assess how far Soviet policies affected the conflict in the Middle East during the Cold War.
Level
A Level
Year Examined
2023
Topic
International history, 1945–92
👑Complete Model Essay
Assess how far Soviet policies affected the conflict in the Middle East during the Cold War.
How Far Did Soviet Policies Affect the Conflict in the Middle East During the Cold War?
The Soviet Union's involvement in the Middle East during the Cold War was a complex and multifaceted affair, driven by a desire to counter American influence, secure strategic interests, and promote its ideological agenda. While Soviet policies undeniably impacted the region, their effectiveness in achieving long-term goals remains debatable. This essay will argue that although the USSR initially achieved some success in expanding its influence and capitalizing on Arab nationalism and anti-Western sentiment, its policies ultimately proved unsustainable and contributed to its declining credibility in the latter stages of the Cold War.
Driven by the overarching goal of achieving parity with the United States, the Soviet Union actively sought to establish a strategic foothold in the Middle East. This ambition manifested in the provision of military aid and support to regional actors, particularly those opposed to Western interests. The 1955 arms deal with Egypt, followed by support for Nasser during the Suez Crisis, exemplified this approach. This strategy yielded immediate benefits for the USSR, securing access to naval and air facilities in Egypt and bolstering its military presence in the Mediterranean. These developments undoubtedly challenged American dominance in the region and enhanced the Soviet Union's nuclear deterrent capabilities by placing its bombers within striking distance of US allies in Europe. This strategically important move had a significant impact on the balance of power in the region.
Furthermore, the Soviets skillfully exploited existing tensions and grievances, most notably the Arab-Israeli conflict, to their advantage. By positioning itself as a staunch ally of Arab states against Israel and the West, the USSR sought to gain favor and influence. This strategy proved particularly effective in the aftermath of the Six-Day War in 1967. The Soviet Union's replenishment of Egyptian arsenals and deployment of military personnel reinforced its image as a reliable protector of Arab interests. However, this approach had the unintended consequence of perpetuating regional instability and hindering the prospects for a lasting peace settlement.
Despite these initial successes, the Soviet Union faced significant limitations in its ability to exert lasting influence in the Middle East. One major obstacle was the limited appeal of communist ideology in a region deeply rooted in nationalism and religious beliefs. Despite attempts to foster communist movements, the USSR was unable to replicate the success it found in other parts of the world. The Iranian Revolution of 1979, which overthrew the US-backed Shah, highlighted the limitations of Soviet influence. Despite being a neighbor of Iran, the USSR had little influence over the events of the revolution and the establishment of the Islamic Republic, demonstrating the limits of its appeal in the region.
The Soviet Union's overreliance on military aid and its unwavering support for allies, even in cases of questionable strategic value, ultimately proved detrimental. The Yom Kippur War of 1973 exposed the limitations of this approach. While the Soviets provided initial support to Egypt and Syria, they were unwilling to risk a wider conflict with the United States. The subsequent US-brokered peace agreements, culminating in the Camp David Accords of 1978, sidelined the Soviet Union and underscored its declining influence in the region. The Camp David Accords, brokered by the US, marginalized the Soviet Union and demonstrated its waning influence. Moreover, the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan in 1979 further tarnished its reputation in the Muslim world, alienating many former Arab allies and reinforcing the perception of the USSR as an imperialist power.
In conclusion, while Soviet policies undeniably affected the dynamics of conflict in the Middle East during the Cold War, their long-term impact proved limited. Although the USSR achieved some early successes in expanding its influence and challenging American hegemony, its policies ultimately proved unsustainable. The Soviet Union's inability to adapt to the region's complexities, its overreliance on military aid, and its waning ideological appeal contributed to its declining credibility and ultimately undermined its position in the Middle East.
**Sources:**
⭐Gaddis, John Lewis. *The Cold War: A New History*. Penguin Books, 2006.
⭐Laqueur, Walter. *The Struggle for the Middle East: The Soviet Union in the Mediterranean, 1958-1968*. Routledge, 2016.
Note: History Study Pack Required
Score Big with Perfectly Structured History Essays!
Prepare effortlessly for your A/AS/O-Level exams with our comprehensive...
History Study Pack.
✅ 1200+ Model Essays: Master your essay writing with expertly crafted answers to past paper questions.
✅ Exam Boards Covered: Tailored materials for AQA, Cambridge, and OCR exams.
🍃 Free Essay Plan
Introduction
Briefly outline the context of the Cold War and the Soviet Union's interests in the Middle East. State your argument: While Soviet policies significantly influenced the Middle East conflict during the Cold War, their impact was ultimately limited by factors beyond their control.
Soviet Goals and Strategies
Exploiting Regional Dynamics: Discuss how the USSR capitalized on Arab nationalism and anti-Western sentiment to gain influence. Provide examples like supporting Egypt and Syria in the Suez Crisis and supplying arms.
Military and Strategic Objectives: Explain the USSR's desire for a Mediterranean presence and how this fueled their support for Arab states. Mention the establishment of bases and the pursuit of nuclear parity with the US.
Impact on Arab-Israeli Conflict
Fueling the Arms Race: Analyze how Soviet arms supplies to Egypt and Syria intensified the Arab-Israeli conflict. Discuss the Six-Day War and the Yom Kippur War as examples.
Mixed Success in Peace Initiatives: Evaluate the USSR's role in peace efforts. Mention their initial support for Egypt but also their opposition to the Camp David Accords. Explain how the US gained the upper hand in peace negotiations.
Limitations of Soviet Influence
Ideological Limits: Discuss the failure of communist ideology to gain traction in the Middle East. Mention Iran as an example of a country resistant to Soviet influence.
Internal Divisions and Regional Conflicts: Analyze how the Iran-Iraq War exposed the limits of Soviet influence and how their conflicting interests with regional actors hampered their goals.
Conclusion
Restate the argument: Soviet policies had a considerable impact on the Middle East conflict during the Cold War, but their influence was ultimately limited. They intensified existing conflicts, gained a temporary foothold, but failed to achieve lasting dominance. The collapse of the USSR marked the end of their ambitions in the region.
Extracts from Mark Schemes
Assess how far Soviet policies affected the conflict in the Middle East during the Cold War.
Soviet policies were designed to ensure that they could achieve parity with the United States by establishing naval and military bases throughout the Middle East. The USSR also wanted to encourage local communist movements as well as support regional conflict providing it with a pretext for intervention and slow the flow of Arab petroleum to the West. The USSR exploited Arab nationalism in both Egypt and Syria as well as the Arab-Israel enmity.
In 1955 it supplied arms to both Egypt and Syria and supported Nasser’s stance in the Suez crisis. This led to Soviet acquisition of naval and air facilities. Its main objective was to ensure US advantage in the area was not achieved but also avoid war with it. Its acquisition of bases in Syria and Egypt enabled it to rival the United States and, with access to strategic bomber bases within range of US European allies, its nuclear deterrent capability was enhanced. The Soviets also acquired the use of Alexandria, Port Said and Latakia providing them with access to the Mediterranean and enabling them to begin a naval build-up in the area and to limit the influence of the United States. The USSR, therefore, made use of anti-American and anti-Israeli sentiment for its own ends.
In 1967, the year of the Six-Day war with Israel, Nasser accepted the presence of Soviet forces in the Mediterranean. After the Arab defeat, the Soviets supplied the Egyptians with more arms and based about 20 000 air and naval personnel in Egypt. It seemed that the USSR was protecting the Arab countries from Israel and the West. The Soviets aimed to maintain tensions as a distraction to the West. The provision of arms and aid in exchange for influence was the sole method of enticing Arab clients to favour the Soviets. Before 1973 this strategy served them well.
However, they made limited progress in areas where there was little anti-American sentiment such as in Iran under the Shah. The Soviets were also unable to spread their communist ideology and were unable to produce a communist revolutionary movement in the Middle East. In 1972 at the Moscow Summit, the Soviets had the dilemma of opposing war and supporting détente or continuing their arms commitment to the Arabs. President Sadat was determined to secure a victory against the Israelis and when the Soviets refused him arms, he expelled their military advisers from Egypt. However, they did agree to support him in the Yom Kippur War of 1973, but both the Soviets and the United States demanded a ceasefire which was supported by the UN. It was Henry Kissinger who secured a series of agreements in 1974–5. Israel agreed to withdraw forces from the Suez Canal area and part of the Golan Heights. Egypt was able to reopen the canal in 1975. Sadat was keen for there to be a Middle East Treaty and it was President Carter who negotiated the Camp David Agreements of 1978 leading to a bilateral treaty between Egypt and Israel in 1979.
The United States responded to Soviet influence in the Middle East after the Camp David Accords by using economic sanctions to influence the Arab world. The Soviets' invasion of Afghanistan in 1979 severely reduced their popularity and credibility in the Arab world. Although Moscow initially reaped rewards from its involvement in the Arab world, it lost diplomatic trust through its policies. For example, Moscow wanted to protect Iraq’s political stability while Tehran aimed to expand its revolution to Iraq. The Iran-Iraq war in 1980 further emphasised Tehran’s and Moscow’s conflict of interest in Iraq. During the war, the USSR supplied Iraq with the most arms. This dissension over Iraq continued until the demise of the USSR in 1991.